|
Building collapses caused by lack of skills. IOL of 20
October 2008. ' Unrealistic costs,
pressure to complete building quickly, cutting corners and lack of both
construction and management skills have contributed to a spate of
construction site collapses, according to Colin de Kock, executive director
of the Master Builders' Association. In the latest
accident, in Little Falls, Roodepoort, where two workers were killed and 15
injured, a little-known company, Dunehill Investments, is the contractor.
The company is listed on the National Homebuilders Registration Council
website as a registered builder. "Although I am not
pointing fingers, no one appears to have heard of this company. We tried to
send someone to investigate, but police would not allow us on site," De Kock
said. Making it clear he was not speaking specifically about last week's
collapse, he said "there is a lack of skills in the industry these days".
Managers had to know basic things like curing times for
cement. Also, builders' clients pushed for time, and tenders came in at
lower prices. "Designs and drawings are also not
perfect. Big developments are under pressure. Cumulatively, this is leading
to these accidents," De Kock said, adding that the construction industry, in
general, did not have a good record for adhering to health and safety
regulations. "What builders and developers do not
understand is that safe sites are productive sites. It costs a bit more
money, but having a neat, clean, safe site sees production improving
overnight," De Kock said. City of Johannesburg
spokesperson Nthatisi Modingoane said the Little Falls office block was not
an illegal development, "in the sense that there were approved building
plans".
"The structural integrity of the building
is, however, the responsibility of a professional engineer, who was
appointed by the developer in February. In terms of the National Building
Regulations, all aspects of construction are under the supervision and
control of an engineer." The building control
directorate had issued a notice to stop all work on the site, Modingoane
added. "The owner has been instructed to appoint a
professional person to investigate the cause of the structural failure, and
further building is not permitted until the report has been provided. The
minister of labour has visited the site, and the department of labour may
also be involved in investigations in terms of the Occupational Health and
Safety Act." Sapa reported on Sunday that the labour
department has been quoted by the SABC as saying the building hadn't
registered with the department. "What we have
determined up until now is that the contractor did not inform the department
that construction was taking place there," said labour department
investigator Kenny Fick. This means health and
safety checks at the site would not have been done by the department.
On Friday, The Star quoted workers at the site as saying
"inspectors" had checked the building the day prior to the collapse and had
told the workers to continue with the construction - but these "inspectors"
were not from the department. Fick said the
department would investigate the cause of the accident in the next few days.
Modingoane pointed out that only a small number of
companies develop without building plans, but in all instances, these were
reported and dealt with. "A major challenge in terms
of illegal development is not with large developments, but the small
additions, alterations and developments on residential properties, and these
are dealt with on an ongoing basis," he said. Perhaps the DoL's attention
should turn to clients / developers?
Click here for a clients duties in
terms of construction regulation 4. RHL.

Will heads roll?
IOL of 20 October 2008. 'Structural
engineers have begun an investigation into the causes of the collapse of a
Roodepoort building and would provide a detailed report on the incident to
the labour department. Department spokesperson Page
Boikanyo said on Monday that the department would only consider its next
action after it had assessed the content of the report.
He was not certain how long the investigation would take.
Labour Minister Membathisi Mdladlana expressed his
condolences to the families of the two men who died.
Mdladlana said employers should ensure that work environments were conducive
to worker safety and that employees had all necessary safety equipment on
hand. On Thursday last week half of a partially
built office block collapsed completely, killing two men and injuring 14 in
Little Falls in Roodepoort, police spokesperson Inspector Balan Muthan
confirmed. He said police would assist in the
criminal investigation and would act if the findings by experts indicated
criminal behaviour. He said all evidence would have
to be gathered and placed before a state prosecutor who would then take a
decision on behalf of the courts on whether to prosecute.
Johannesburg emergency management services spokesperson
Percy Morokane identified the dead as Malawian Arnold Mwale, 19, and
Mozambican Arthur Nombora, 24.
Nombora's body was trapped under the rubble until emergency
workers retrieved it on Saturday.
Probe into collapsed Roodepoort
building begins. SABC of 20 October 2008. 'Structural engineers
are expected to begin their assessment today of the building which collapsed
in Little Falls in Roodepoort, west of Johannesburg last week.
Three workers were killed and three others injured in Thursday's collapse of
a partially completed building. The Labour Department says that it has a
security company that is ensuring that no activity is taking place at the
site until investigations into the collapse of the three-storey building are
completed. “We are also investigating the actual operation itself, the
business, the contractor that is building that site to ensure that all their
plans, their permission, their certificates everything is in order and we
should have a clearer picture by Tuesday or Wednesday in the week,” says
department's spokesperson, Kenny Fick.
R'poort building
not registered.
News24 of 18 October 2008. 'The building
that collapsed in Roodepoort, killing two, was not registered with the
Labour Department, SABC reported on Saturday. "What
we have determined up until now is that the contractor did not inform the
department that construction was taking place here," said Labour Department
investigator Kenny Fick. This means health and safety checks at the site
would not have been done by the department. Fick said the department would
be investigating the cause of the accident in the next few days. "We need to
talk to the inspectors and the Jo'burg Metro to determine what they've done,
and how this plan was approved, and that we'll be doing in the coming week."
SABC also said a demolition expert will be called in to accurately assess
what remains of the building. The department apparently hopes to flatten it.
On Saturday, the body of a man was discovered in the rubble of the collapsed
Little Falls office block under construction. Police spokesperson Inspector
Karen Jacobs said the body was discovered around 09:30. Johannesburg
Emergency Services spokesperson Percy Morokane identified the body as
belonging to 25-year-old Artur Nombora from Myembane province in Mozambique.
One other person was killed and fourteen were injured in the building
collapse. Nombora's brother, Jorge Magerizane, told the SABC on Saturday:
"I'm hurting. "My brother's body must now go back home, and we don't have
money to transport him. "Maybe the South African government can help us."
I assume by 'registering' the building
they are referring to Notification of Construction Work? It is also highly
improbable that DoL inspectors would have visiting the scene upon such
notification. Click here
for construction regulation 3. RHL.
Body found in
building rubble.
News24 of 18 October 2008. 'The body of a man was
discovered in the rubble of a collapsed Little Falls office block under
construction in Roodepoort on Saturday, Gauteng police said. Inspector Karen
Jacobs speaking from the scene said the body was discovered around 09:30 on
Saturday. Heavy earth moving equipment had managed to excavate large parts
of the rubble and cleared much of the top rubble around an area where rescue
dogs had reacted earlier. The body of the man was discovered in the area
rescue workers had been digging out since Thursday. The identity of the man
would be established to determine if he was the missing builder identified
by the Star newspaper as 23-year-old Artur Magaizane.
Police photographers would now document the
scene for investigative purposes, Jacobs said
Minister: Boss knew of cracks.
News24 of 18 October 2008. 'Labour Minister Membathisi Mdladlana alleged
that the employer at the construction site where a partially built office
collapsed in Little Falls, Roodepoort on Thursday had been aware of cracks
in the construction. The Star newspaper reported on Friday that Mdladlana
said the workers had complained about cracks in the walls but that their
employer insisted they continue working on the site. "We heard building
inspectors were here but they are not from the Department of Labour. They
alleged it was safe while workers saw cracks in it (the structure)," he told
the newspaper. A construction worker who had been on site when the building
fell, Joseph Nevhuhlulu, said there had been cracks in the building for the
past few weeks and alleged that the owner was aware of it. The building
started shaking on Wednesday and inspectors were called to the site but
workers were instructed to continue working after the site was found to be
safe. The Department of Labour had issued the construction company
responsible for the site, Dunehill Investments, with a notice of prohibition
to stop work on the site until the department had finished its
investigations. Efforts to speak to the employer failed because he referred
them to his lawyers, Mdladlana told the newspaper, and information had to be
gleaned from an injured worker. Honeydew police Inspector Karen Jacobs said
attempts to rescue a trapped worker had stopped around 22:00 on Thursday
because the area where sniffer dogs had reacted and rescuers were working
had started to collapse. Rescue work resumed at 06:00 on Friday. The worker
was still believed to be missing under the rubble. She added that the top
part of the rubble had become extremely unstable. Engineers were being
called in to advise on how to proceed. They would decide on the correct way
to proceed with the rescue effort. At present rescue workers were excavating
the rubble from the side using heavy earth moving equipment.
Shoddy work behind
collapse?. News24 of 17 October 2008. ' Experts
suspect shoddy workmanship was behind the collapse of a building in
Roodepoort which killed a young construction worker on Thursday morning.
Arnold Mwale, 19, was killed when half of the nearly completed office block,
in the Little Falls area of Roodepoort, collapsed at 08:15 on Thursday.
"It's unclear why it collapsed, but what we hear from the experts here is
that it was shoddy work," Johannesburg emergency services spokesperson Percy
Morokane told News24. He was under instructions from the contracting company
responsible for the building not to disclose their name. Half of the
building fell in when the top two stories collapsed onto the bottom storey.
Thirteen other workers at the site were seriously injured while one was
critically injured. Rescue workers were searching the rubble for another
worker, believed to be trapped. Morokane said 28 rescue workers, including
teams from the police dog unit, were at work despite the dangers the site
still posed. "It's a serious exercise because one section of the building is
still standing and there are cracks showing so there is a great risk," he
said of continuing rescue operations. "We can't rule out that there might be
other people trapped." Mwale's brother, Kenneth, who worked at a building
opposite the construction site, was at the scene on Thursday afternoon. The
two had worked in South Africa for the past five months. Meanwhile Sapa
reported that the mass of rubble as wide and broad as four tennis courts,
was very unstable with rescue workers stepping gingerly and keeping to
stable areas only. Emergency workers had cleared rubble by hand around an
area where rescue dogs from the police dog unit were at work, attempting to
locate the missing construction worker. But the sniffer dogs were being
distracted by the scent of the construction workers' bags. Rescue efforts
were further being hampered by rubble continuously shifting and settling
into the hole where the missing man was presumed to be located.
Representatives from the Department of Labour were on scene as well as
officials from the city's building control section, Morokane said.
Two die, four
trapped as building collapses.
IOL of 16 October 2008. 'Four workers were still trapped
inside the remains of a 20m-high building that collapsed in Little Falls,
west of Joburg this morning, claiming the lives of two others.
Fifteen workers were rescued and transported to hospital
after sustaining injuries during the fall. One had
to be airlifted to Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital with serious injuries.
Emergency Services spokesperson, Percy Morokane said 40
workers were on site when an office they were building collapsed at about
8.15am on Thursday. By 11am, personnel from the EMS
rescue team and SA Police Service Dog Unit were still searching for those
still trapped. An eyewitness, Stallo Paraskeva, told The Star that she was
sitting in the balcony a few metres away when she heard a "hectic rumble".
"I thought the noise might be coming from the basement.
When I looked I realised that the building was shaking and moving. Soon
after, the building collapsed," she said. Paraskeva
said she saw panicking construction workers - who had been on the roof -
jumping down. She said those who were inside seemed
to have been trapped. Workers who managed to jump
down ran, trying to help their colleagues, she said, adding that she then
called the emergency services. A shaken builder who
was on the roof when the building collapsed said he jumped and ran to try to
help his colleagues who were working inside. "We
were scared to go inside because we were not sure whether the rest of the
building was going to collapse," he said, claiming that they saw some cracks
on the building when they arrived at work yesterday morning and reported
this to the foreman. He said the foreman called the
construction owner who then summoned inspectors to the site. The inspectors
apparently said it was safe for the workers to continue working.
However, The Star could not confirm with developers, who
said they were only going to comment once the situation has been brought
under control. At the time of going to press, the
rescue workers were busy removing rubble to search for the four trapped
inside the building. Rescuers
search for survivors after a Little Falls building collapsed this morning.
Gold Fields reopens Kloof, Driefontein after deaths.
Mining News of 20 October 2008. 'South African gold
producer Gold Fields on Friday stated that the
Section 54
Orders at both the Driefontein and Kloof gold mines had been lifted by the
Department of Minerals and Energy, and that both operations had resumed
production. The Section 54 Order was lifted at the
Kloof mine on Friday morning, after consultation with the join safety
committee on the mine, regarding the remedial action that needed to be
taken. The Driefontein operations were opened on Thursday evening.
Gold Fields halted all operations at the Driefontein mine
on Wednesday, after a seismic event in which one worker was killed and four
were injured, while another miner was still trapped 3 000 m underground at
the time. The Kloof mine had been shut since
Tuesday, after a miner was killed when a section of the tunnel he was
working in, collapsed.
Alarm bells ring for SA buildings. The Times of 17 October
2008. 'THE increase in construction and growth in the
building industry has led to higher risk and an increase in work-related
injuries. National Union of Mineworkers spokesman
Lesiba Seshoka said the union had noted a rise in the number of fatalities
and injuries, adding that “smaller building contractors are problematic”.
Seshoka said NUM had succeeded in getting union-appointed
safety officials to monitor three construction sites following protracted
strike action. He said the department of labour’s
inspectorate division was “too weak” and unable to enforce safety standards.
Another worker dies at
Kloof Mine. Busrep of 17 October 2008. 'Another
Gold Fields (GFI) mineworker has died, this time at the Kloof Mine,
according to the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM).
It said the victim had been killed in a
rockfall on Monday night. The union reiterated its call for the release of
the Presidential Safety Audit Report ordered by former President Thabo Mbeki
in October last year. "The NUM believes that the release of the report is
long overdue and that the report is likely to bring all parties up to speed
with the state of safety in South African mines," the union said in a media
statement.
Vergasser bars
en skud Sasol-aanleg.
Die Beeld van 10 Oktober 2008. 'Secunda. – Werkers by Sasol
se gasaanleg hier het eergisteraand groot geskrik toe ’n vergasser oopgebars
het. Die slag het glo die omliggende gebied geskud
en ’n swart wolk het toegesak.
Volgens mnr. Johann van Rheede, Sasol se woordvoerder, het
die vergasser-wand geskeur en gas ontsnap. “Altesame 13 mense is by die
mediese stasie vir geringe gas-inaseming behandel,” het hy gesê. Die voorval
beïnvloed nie die aanleg se produksie nie. Die oorsaak word ondersoek, het
hy gesê.
Labour laws needs a revamp - Mdladlana. IOL of 14 October
2008. 'The enforcement of labour law needs to be revamped
as it is not sufficiently protecting workers' rights, labour minister
Membathisi Mdladlana said on Monday. Speaking at the
8th National Union of Mineworkers Congress in Vanderbijlpark, Mdladlana said
the exploitation of workers was being compounded by the increasing use of
labour brokers. "Informality has become the name of
the game by labour brokers and yet people want us to believe that our labour
market is rigid. How can it be rigid with the subcontracting that is so
common?" he said. "If it was rigid, it would be
difficult for chief executives of companies to retrench workers with such
ease." Unemployment in the informal sector has
increased by 20 000 between March and July this year due to a sharp decline
in formal employment, said Mdladlana. "A rise in
informal sector employment shows a need for the creation of decent work
agenda to protect the rights of workers," he said
Labour inspectors assaulted in KZN.
IOL of 10 October 2008. 'The Labour Department is taking
criminal action after the assault of two of its inspectors in KwaZulu-Natal
in the past two weeks, it said on Thursday. "Those
found to be guilty of such an offence will be dealt with by the full might
of the inspectorate," said Labour Minister Membathisi Mdladlana, who in
condemning the attacks, warned that no-one was above the law.
"An inspector of the department has the power to visit any
employer at any time to conduct inspections. "Anyone
who obstructs or hinders an inspector from performing this function, is
breaking the law," he said. One of the inspectors
was receiving medical treatment after being sworn at and physically attacked
by the son of an employer at a Ladysmith printing business where he was
conducting a follow-up inspection, the department said in a statement.
"He suffered a cut on the face, had a swollen lump on his
head and cracks to the ribs, while his jacket and shirt were torn."
He had been re-visiting the business after finding in his
initial inspection that workers were being allowed a meal interval of only
15 minutes and that there was no valid first aid certificate.
"The department has since opened an obstruction case in
terms of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act against the employer.
"A criminal charge has also been opened for the assault of
the inspector," the department said. The second
incident was in Pietermaritzburg, where an employer "verbally abused and
physically handled" an inspector there to discuss injury-on-duty
compensation. This, after media reports about
foreign employees being doused with thinners and set alight by their
employer, who accused them of stealing diesel and spares.
"An obstruction charge is also being processed against this
employer, while a criminal assault charge has already been opened with the
police," the department said. "The inspector is also
receiving medical treatment".
Mdladlana expressed his sympathies with the injured officials.
Killed miner
'didn't wear harness'.
News24 of 9 October 2008. 'A miner has died in an accident
at DRD Gold's Blyvooruitzicht mine near Carletonville, an official confirmed
on Thursday. "The employee, who worked as an operator on the shaft's
underground ore loading station some 1 900 metres below surface, was
reported missing mid-afternoon yesterday [Wednesday] and his body was
recovered from the loading station's loading flask at approximately 23:00,"
said DRD Gold spokesperson James Duncan. He said the mine worker was not
wearing his safety gear. "Initial indications are that the employee was not
wearing a full-body safety harness, which is part of the standard safety
equipment required to be worn by employees working in such situations," said
Duncan. "The employee's safety helmet, cap lamp and lamp belt were found at
the loading station. It is mandatory that all of these items are worn at all
times while employees are underground." The National Union of Mineworkers
(NUM) said the mine needed to explain why he was not wearing his safety
belt. NUM spokesperson Lesiba Seshoka said this was the seventh death at a
DRD Gold mine in the past two months, but Duncan said it was the fifth death
since the beginning of the year. Both were adamant that their number was
correct. The Solidarity trade union last week said three miners die in
accidents in South Africa every week. "In the past 40 weeks, 135 employees
have already died on South African mines. This means that more than three
mineworkers currently die in
accidents each week," said union spokesperson Jaco Kleynhans.
Worker crushed
to death on site.
News24 of 9 October 2008. ' A
worker was killed when a concrete pillar fell on him at a demolition site in
Rosebank, Johannesburg, paramedics said. "The 58-year-old worker, driving a
concrete chipper tractor was busy trying to break a pillar on the first
floor on the Volkswagen building which was being demolished at 09:20," said
spokesperson Percy Morokane. "However, the concrete pillar fell on him,
crushing him to death. All work has been suspended on the site and labour
department inspectors were at the scene. Morokane said the building was
declared unstable and unsafe. Emergency workers were by midday still trying
to remove the man's body from the collapsed pillar. "We are working
tirelessly to remove the body using heavy rescue equipment," said Morokane.
More |